As we emerged into 2009 we found acceleration
in job losses, a continuation of the stock market slide
that kept consumer confidence down and many questions
surrounding what programs the new administration
might implement. This compelled many to sit
back and wait for some clarity before giving consideration
to home purchases. Combine that mindset with
an inability to find mortgage money and you have the
environment for our 1st quarter of 2009.
Table Number 1
| Month-Year |
Inventory |
Sales |
ADOM |
| January 03 |
7,953 |
1,197 |
54 |
| June 03 |
7,448 |
1,769 |
58 |
| January 04 |
6,605 |
1,512 |
66 |
| June 04 |
4,360 |
2,952 |
47 |
| January 05 |
3,317 |
1,695 |
46 |
| June 05 |
3,710 |
2,883 |
29 |
| January 06 |
12,015 |
1,917 |
46 |
| June 06 |
18,437 |
2,841 |
57 |
| January 07 |
21,266 |
1,469 |
90 |
| June 07 |
25,923 |
1,524 |
98 |
| Jan 08 |
25,724 |
813 |
117 |
| March 08 |
25,472 |
1,120 |
128 |
| June 08 |
24,575 |
1,443 |
123 |
| September 08 |
24,690 |
1,394 |
112 |
| December 08 |
22,524 |
1,305 |
109 |
| January 09 |
22,613 |
1,305 |
109 |
| February 09 |
22,168 |
1,322 |
100 |
| March 09 |
21,448 |
1,653 |
104 |
Data from Orlando Regional Realtor Association
Let’s fast forward to the present and view the
actual results of our first quarter of 2009. Nationally,
regionally and most importantly locally, all
our indicators we traditionally track (see Table 1)
are showing positive trends: Inventory for the first
quarter while taking a slight seasonable up tick in
January continued to recede to 21,448. This number
needs to continue trending towards between 15,000
and 16,000 for meaningful progress. Actual Closed
contracts have after a seasonable pause in January
showed strong growth through March with 1,050,
1,322 and then a large jump to 1,653. These figures
are welcomed as they show buyers beginning to come
into the market after a prolonged absence. Average
Days on Market (ADOM) has stagnated somewhat
but is still just over 100 days signaling a significant
portion of short sales which have prolonged selling
times. And while I haven’t usually reported on Pending
Sales that metric is now being watched as its’ ongoing
increase predicts potential contract closings to
come. Numbers for the first quarter are all over 2,000
which haven’t happened since April of 2008. January
through March figures are 2,282, 2,434 and 2,956.
Myriad of Government and Fed Programs
Some of these results come from a myriad of programs
specifically targeted to stimulate real estate
growth, correct and improve financial elements of our
society thereby hopefully course correcting a significant
portion of our economy. These programs really
just commenced and are therefore anemic in their affect
and should become significantly more influential
in the 2nd and 3rd quarter of this year. But nonetheless
the following programs are beginning to take effect:
- Most directly affecting real estate is the first time
buyer’s $8,000 house tax credit. This is significant in
that it is a tax credit and even individuals who have
not owned a home in the last three years are said to
qualify. Over time it is expected that entry of buyers
into the first time portion of the market will begin to
trigger chain reaction movement of those who want
to move up or down in housing requirements.
- Critical to funding all transactions and removing
toxicity from the financial sector are programs designed
to lower interest rates and create more financial
liquidity:
- TARP (Troubled Asset Relief Program) and -
- TALF (Term Asset-Backed Securities Loan
Facility) both have design intent to improve
banking capital positions and -/li>
- A mid March announcement by the Federal
Reserve that they were buying $300 billion
dollars in long term securities and –
- Another Treasury purchase of securities issued
by Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae in the amount
of $850 billion in agency backed securities,
bringing total purchases to $1,250 billion
dollars.
- Additionally the Financial Accounting Standards
Board (FASB) in early April decided to allow banks
more leeway in determining what their assets are really
worth. The five-member Financial Accounting
Standards Board voted unanimously to let banks
exercise more judgment in using mark-to-market accounting
that has forced billions of dollars in writedowns
and been blamed (by some) for worsening the
recession. With the new mark-to-market accounting
rules banks can potentially improve earnings and capital
levels and thereby increase lending activities.
The overall result of the above actions: Banks and
financial institutions are beginning to report profits
and healthier projections and therefore resources for
mortgages are coming online again, and buyers are in
the marketplace searching for homes. This continues
to decrease housing inventory which further stimulates
buyer activity. In other words, we are seeing the
potential for the housing market to stabilize this year
as some have predicted.
The Challenge of Distressed Inventory and Home Values
The other critical factor that we hope to see corrected
are our home values. This past two years the
“perfect housing-financial storm” has battered home
prices to 2003 values and even below. According to
Lawrence Yun, Chief Economist, National Association
of Realtors Research, “The current home price
is the lowest since March 2003” and there is concern
about prices continuing to fall and over correcting
from their highs of 2005 and 2006. There are indications
that “the high prevalence of distressed home
sales and of those in the lower price range has skewed
the median price markedly lower than under normal
market conditions” Yun says. And Yun reports that
“Distressed sales, as defined as foreclosed properties
or those requiring lender mediated short sales, account
for about 45% of all sales.” He suggests that
of our total inventory strictly distressed properties
is about 25%. And relative to valuation, distressed
and non-distressed, our non-distressed properties are
holding their value much better than distressed ones.
The hopeful sign from this analysis is that if 45% of
the sales are distressed properties it may not take as
long as some have predicted to get through the inventory
if they constitute 25% of the total. With activity
picking up we could have exponential impact on the
distressed inventory at a pace of 45% of all sales. The
effect of declining distressed inventory will really support
the stabilization of home values. However, the
distressed inventory represents a significant challenge
in the coming months as non-distressed sellers’ battle
with buyers who assume everything on the market
is a deal. Not until the distressed inventory is pared
down considerably will we see home prices stabilize
so any increase in the rate at which we can lessen the
distressed inventory is a very positive activity.
I Can See the Corner for Stabilization
So, with the first time home buyer tax credits, the
programs for banks and financial institutions hopefully
increasing bank capital for mortgages and the
upward trending housing statistics can we expect to
turn the corner this year? Certainly we are headed
in the right direction and maybe we can even see the
corner approaching. However, we still have a way to
go and some rather significant financial, housing and
economic hurdles to overcome before we can move
out of this current crisis. Our all important consumer
confidence levels have shown slight improvements recently
and hopefully the anticipation of continued job
losses for several months to come won’t portend any
back sliding. And we will have to carefully watch the
auto industry as the outcome of GM and Chrysler
will have a very compelling effect on consumer confidence.
But with all things being considered I still believe
we will see housing stabilization this year which
should set the stage for us to come closer to market
recovery next year.