Incredible as it may seem it is already July and I
am writing this article for a late summer-fall publication.
It seemed just a couple of months ago I was
looking at 08 fourth quarter data hoping the slight
positive trends I saw emerging were real and reliable
enough to forecast improvement in our local real estate
market. We have indeed seen continued improvement
in reduced inventory and constant percentage
gains in actual closed contracts. We may even have
slight evidence that the eroding values of our homes
might be sputtering into an environment of the long
hoped for period of stabilization.
A review of the Orlando Regional Realtor Association
statistics that are restated with sample data
going back to 2003 shows very large swings in the
categories mentioned.
Table Number 1
| Month-Year |
Inventory |
Sales |
ADOM |
| January 03 |
7,953 |
1,197 |
54 |
| June 03 |
7,448 |
1,769 |
58 |
| January 04 |
6,605 |
1,512 |
66 |
| June 04 |
4,360 |
2,952 |
47 |
| January 05 |
3,317 |
1,695 |
46 |
| June 05 |
3,710 |
2,883 |
29 |
| January 06 |
12,015 |
1,917 |
46 |
| June 06 |
18,437 |
2,841 |
57 |
| January 07 |
21,266 |
1,469 |
90 |
| June 07 |
25,923 |
1,524 |
98 |
| Jan 08 |
25,724 |
813 |
117 |
| March 08 |
25,472 |
1,120 |
128 |
| June 08 |
24,575 |
1,443 |
123 |
| September 08 |
24,690 |
1,394 |
112 |
| December 08 |
22,524 |
1,305 |
109 |
| January 09 |
22,613 |
1,305 |
109 |
| February 09 |
22,168 |
1,322 |
100 |
| March 09 |
21,448 |
1,754 |
103 |
| April 09 |
20,194 |
1,854 |
102 |
| May 09 |
19,123 |
1,882 |
103 |
| June 09 |
17,831 |
2,131 |
104 |
Data from Orlando Regional Realtor Association
Most significant is our inventory which has really
started decreasing from the June 07 number of
25,923 to June of this year’s 17,831. The good news
is that is a much needed drop of over 8,092 homes
but the fact that it took two years to accomplish the
decrease is the bad news. Nonetheless, it is the correction
we need. The steady increase in sold homes
will hopefully continue to decrease the inventory as
more distressed properties are forecast to enter the
market for this year and possibly into next. Since this
January we have witnessed the steady increase in sold
properties from 1,050 to this June’s 2,131. With the
exception of seasonal lulls (beginning of school and
the coming holidays) I am hopeful to see sold properties
continue its upper momentum and reach 2,300.
Also, an indication of the elongated selling times that
distressed properties bring to our inventory is the fact
that Average Days on Market (ADOM) continues to
exceed 100 days.
Additionally, there have been some small but
hopeful signs of price stabilization. For the first time
in a very long time ORRA reports the median price
from April to May was stable at $130,000. Even
more encouraging was the median had a slight increase
to $131,200 May to June. The average price
also jumped from $155,900 in May to $161,000 for
June. We will have to watch these metrics closely next
month to see if it is an anomalous blip or the start of
actual stabilization. It is more likely a blip but one
of several we can expect over the next six to eight
months while pricing (median & average) fluctuates
between increases and decreases month over month
eventually stabilizing before reaching (hopefully) a
small but constant appreciation some time next year.
This fluctuation in price is a direct result of the
complexity of our inventory. Instead of being just
the number of homes on the market, inventory has
morphed into multiple strata in different categories
based on seller motivation, unrealistic or realistic
pricing points, and varying degrees of financially and
or physically distressed conditions.
The first strata of inventory is the portion that
sellers and agents have not priced the property to current
downward market conditions and are “chasing
the market” and are not catching it. These properties
are therefore on the market an elongated time and continue to lose value in addition to becoming stale.
Overpriced short sales can be part of the strata and
“chase the market” as well.
Second strata is those homes that entered the
market as destressed properties (foreclosures and
short sales) and are increased over time from the first
strata that eventual become depressed because of incorrect
listing prices. Again, this incremental increase
from the first strata is because they were chasing the
market and didn’t catch it and in some cases became
a short sale or foreclosure.
And the final stratum is that portion of our inventory
where sellers and agents understand current
market conditions and have priced the property accordingly.
This portion also is well maintained and
is therefore very attractive and most likely to have
many showings and even quick and or multiple offers.
While this phenomena can happen at all pricing
ranges it typically happens below the $450,000 price
point.
Adding to this schizophrenic nature of our inventory
is the massive influx of condo units. Acting
to drive the local, regional and national prices down
these transactions can cause volatile swings in metrics
because they are well below median price ranges
and can be snapped up in large numbers by first time
home buyers and investors.
But we ARE making progress as the numbers
continue to show each month and each quarter. Our
real estate agent population needs to continue to take
strong positions with sellers by clearly conveying the
market conditions and how that affects the price that
a property will ultimately obtain. Our agent population
must also work with buyers to make sure that
the perceived “Deals” in short sales and foreclosures
are received with trade offs in prolonged contract
times and frequently physical depressed property
conditions. In short, seller’s need to stop chasing the
market and price the home to market conditions and
buyers must realize not everything on the market is a
fire sale.
As we move through this next six month period
of inventory complexity, price point issues for listings
and un-realistic buyer expectation on obtaining deals
on distressed properties will possibly self correct with
slow movement to a more normal real estate environment.
We are headed in the correct direction so keep
your fingers crossed that we stay on the course and
have the same incremental improvements for the upcoming
quarters as we have had for the last one.